How to Make a Crib More Comfortable (Safely): Why the Mattress Is Firm, and What to Do Instead
With Avery, my first, I pressed on her brand-new crib mattress and thought it was hard as a rock. How was she supposed to sleep on that? I worried about it until I learned that firm is the whole point. That hardness is a safety feature.
So if you’re searching for how to make a crib mattress softer, here’s the honest answer, and the safe ways to make the crib cozier instead.
Can you make a crib mattress softer? The quick answer
No, and you shouldn’t try. Babies under 1 need a firm, flat sleep surface that doesn’t indent when they’re lying on it. The AAP says mattress toppers, which are made to soften a surface, aren’t safe for babies under 1. (HealthyChildren.org, AAP; AAP 2022 safe sleep recommendations) Make the room comfortable instead: the right temperature, a sleep sack, a snug fitted sheet and a calm routine.
| Instead of… | Try… |
|---|---|
| A topper, pillow-top or memory foam pad | Leave the mattress firm, as designed |
| Blankets and quilts | A wearable blanket (sleep sack) |
| Piling on layers | One layer more than you’re wearing |
| Bumpers, pillows or positioners | A bare crib with just a fitted sheet |
| Flipping to the softer toddler side early | Wait until after 12 months, per the label |
Why crib mattresses are so firm
A soft surface can sink in around a baby’s face, and young babies can’t always turn away from it. The AAP warns that soft, adjustable and memory-foam mattresses are dangerous for infants for exactly this reason. (AAP 2022 safe sleep recommendations)
That’s why, since August 2022, crib mattresses sold in the US have had to pass a federal firmness test. (CPSC) What feels hard to us is what’s safe for them.

How to check your crib mattress firmness at home

- Press the center with your palm, then lift your hand. A firm mattress springs back right away and doesn’t keep the shape of your hand.
- Press the edges and corners. They should feel as firm as the middle, with no sagging.
- Check it under weight. A firm surface doesn’t indent when your baby is lying on it. (HealthyChildren.org, AAP)
- Look for a dip. Lay a straight edge (a broom handle works) across the mattress. There should be no gap in the middle.
- Check the fit. If more than two fingers fit between the mattress and the crib’s sides or ends, the gap is too big. (HealthyChildren.org, AAP)
If your mattress fails any of these, it’s time to replace it. More in do crib mattresses expire?
Safe ways to make the crib more comfortable
Get the temperature right. Dress your baby in no more than one layer more than you’re wearing, and watch for overheating: sweating, or a chest that feels hot. (HealthyChildren.org, AAP)
Use a sleep sack instead of a blanket. The AAP prefers a wearable blanket to loose blankets, and says weighted sleep sacks and swaddles aren’t safe. (HealthyChildren.org, AAP; AAP 2022 safe sleep recommendations)

Stop swaddling once your baby tries to roll. Arms-in swaddles should stop at the first signs of rolling. (AAP 2022 safe sleep recommendations)
Choose a soft, snug fitted sheet. A breathable cotton sheet made for crib mattresses feels soft against your baby’s skin without adding any cushioning. Tug the corners to check it can’t pull loose.
Make the room sleep-friendly. A dim room and the same calm bedtime routine every night help more than any mattress could.
Offer a pacifier at sleep time. The AAP suggests offering one at naps and bedtime (once breastfeeding is going well, if you’re nursing). (HealthyChildren.org, AAP)
Kelleigh’s Quick Tip: Before you blame the mattress for bad sleep, feel the back of your baby’s neck. Too warm or too cold is a much more common reason for waking than a “hard” mattress.
What not to add to the crib
- Mattress toppers, pillow-tops or egg-crate foam
- Pillows, quilts, comforters or loose blankets
- Bumpers of any kind
- Sleep positioners or wedges
- Stuffed animals
The AAP recommends keeping all of these out of a baby’s sleep space. (AAP 2022 safe sleep recommendations)
What about after the first birthday?
Many crib mattresses have a slightly softer toddler side. Switch to it only after 12 months, and only when your mattress label says so. More in when to flip a crib mattress.
FAQs
Why are crib mattresses so hard?
Because firm is safer for babies. A soft surface can sink in around a baby’s face and raise the risk of suffocation. Since 2022, US crib mattresses have had to pass a federal firmness test.
How firm should a baby mattress be?
Firm enough that it doesn’t indent when your baby lies on it, and springs back right away when you press it with your hand.
Can I put a mattress topper on a crib mattress?
No. The AAP says mattress toppers aren’t safe for babies under 1.
Can I use a waterproof mattress cover?
Yes, if it’s thin, made for crib mattresses and fits snugly without adding padding.
How can I make my baby’s crib more comfortable?
Keep the mattress firm and the crib bare, and make the room comfortable instead: the right temperature, a sleep sack, a snug cotton fitted sheet and a calm routine.
My take
I was so sure Avery’s mattress was too hard. It wasn’t. It was doing its job. Leave the mattress firm and the crib bare, focus on temperature and routine, and save the cozy extras for when your little one is older.
Questions about your own baby’s sleep space? Email me at kelleigh@imperfecthomemaking.com.
Happy parenting!
Related reading:
